The
False Teaching
A
Catholic source:"This is seen in their interpretation of the key
biblical passage, chapter six of John’s Gospel, in which Christ speaks
about the sacrament that will be instituted at the Last Supper." An Episcopalian
Source: Receiving our Lord's Body and Blood in the Eucharist is
necessary for eternal salvation.. "So Jesus said to them, Truly,
Truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and
drink his blood, you have no life in you. . . . he who eats this
bread will live forever." (v:53-58)
From
A Protestant source: "Here, then, is some of the deepest New
Testament teaching about the Eucharist. The focus of this teaching is
on sacrifice and shared life. These are inseparable since there is no
sharing of life without the laying down of life. The once-for-all
sacrifice of Christ is the pouring out of his life for the life of the
world, bringing forgiveness and a new power of life. That sacrifice
also shows us the deepest reality about God--his love--and about life:
all true life is sacrificial. Life is a matter of exchange: my life for
yours, yours for mine. In this sacrificial web of exchange we find the
communion, the community, of the Godhead. At Eucharist we receive into
ourselves, into our bodies and souls, the life-giving power of God, and
precisely by eating and drinking we proclaim the Lord's once-for-all
death until he comes."
False!
False!
False!
|
Exposing
the Error
So
Jesus said to them, Truly, truly,
I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his
blood, you have no life in you;(v:53)
This
is the maximum
offense to Jews, for it is written:Whoever
eats any blood, that person shall be
cut off from his people(Lev.7:27) ,That
is why he said it - to offend them. Why? The context is very clear. He
had fed 5000 men with five loaves and two fish the day before and they
wanted to forceably make him their king. He withdrew into the hills by
himself
and, next day, they found him and he rebuked them: Truly, truly, I say to you, you seek
me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate your fill of the
loaves (v:26).They
had bad motives and were trying to force him to their will. Therefore
he tested all of them, including the Twelve. So he said to them, Do you take offense at this (v:61)?
After this, many of
his disciples drew back and no longer went about with him (v.66).
That was the intended result. The bad
motives left. Then, to the Twelve, Will you also go away (v.66)?
Peter
said,"Lord, to whom shall
we go? You have the words of eternal life; and we have believed....that
you are the Holy
One of God." There is not one word here pertaining to the
Eucharist! He was screening his disciples - nothing more. By
implication, we also learn that Jesus never instituted the Eucharist,
so called, for he would have know that his words here would be confused
with it and he would have chosen some other screen.
Listen
to the Good Shepherd
|
Declaring
the Truth
His Word is Truth. He would not
have set this screen were it not true. He introduced it so: Truly truly I say to you, the one believing
has eternal life. I am
the bread of life.Your
fathers ate the manna in the
wilderness and died. This is the bread coming down from heaven, in
order that anyone who eat of it also not die. I am the living bread having come down
out of heaven. If anyone eat of this bread, he will live to eternity.(v.47-51)
The bread is clearly a metaphor;
no one, on seeing him, observed a
talking loaf. He gives these clues to his Truth: I am the bread of life; the one
coming to me will not hunger, and the one believing
in me will not thirst ever (v.35).
But I said to you
that you have seen me and do not believe (v.36).
It seems that he intends them (and us)
to believe something - and
what can this be but his words? So to be certain that everyone
understands, including us, he hastened to say this: The spirit is that which makes alive, the flesh profits nothing. The words which I have spoken
to you are spirit and life. But there are some among you who do not
believe
(v 63,64). It's all
about believing, and how can one believe flesh? It's the words,
the words, the words, the words! Some say that, in the Eucharist,
the bread, by transubstatiation,
becomes the actual flesh of Jesus. So? "the
flesh profits
nothing." The Eucharist, with its
'my body' profits nothing! More
Listen! Believe!
|